Fake defenses in the Council on Economics of the Russian State Humanitarian University, 2003-2012 - enlarge .
The mass occurrence of fake dissertations in a particular council or university is not an accident, but the result of the deliberate work of a large group of associate professors, professors, members of the dissertation council and employees of “friendly” organizations who “wave” positive reviews compiled in advance. In fact, the factories of fake dissertations are an organized network of officials, businessmen, teachers, which has nothing to do with conducting research and increasing scientific knowledge.
 |
To date, Dissernet has discovered 52 fake dissertations defended in this council in 2003-2012, and during its investigations identified 148 more persons (supervisors, opponents, authors of source dissertations) who accompanied the process of defending fake dissertations. All two hundred factory participants turned out to be, as the figure shows, interconnected in a single network. The evolution of these connections is also clearly shown in.
The factory for the production of fake economists with degrees at the Russian State University for the Humanities has its own characteristics. Of the 52 fake dissertations defended at the Russian State Humanitarian University, only 20 were directly prepared at this university. The remaining 32 dissertations were brought in from outside. The main supplier of linden is the Moscow State Institute of Electronics and Mathematics, where Fedor Fedorovich Sterlikov worked.
He personally participated in 17 unfair defenses at the Russian State Humanitarian University. It would be wrong to assume that only the odious Professor Sterlikov created a wave of plagiarism in this dissertation council. Undoubtedly, his role in this is great, however, in order to accompany 52 defenses, other scientific supervisors, opponents, and representatives of leading organizations are also needed. So, in the RSUH factory, 32 holders of scientific degrees directly participated in fake defenses at least twice. Among them there are also permanent actors who accompanied the lime as scientific advisers and opponents (see table).
The data indicate that a group of people from a number of “friendly” universities at that time (PFUR, Moscow State University of Medicine and Dentistry, Moscow State Institute of Electronics and Mathematics (MGIEM), Moscow State University of Railways messages, the Moscow State University of Technology and Management named after K. G. Razumovsky, etc.), which systematically covered fake dissertations. Among them are the leaders of the Dissernet in the absolute standings: F.F. Sterlikov (28 dissertations, 17 of them at the Russian State University for the Humanities, I place), I.V. Ryzhov (23 theses, 5 at the Russian State University for the Humanities, IV place), O.I. Pilipenko (22 dissertations, 6 at the Russian State University for the Humanities, 5th place).
In addition, the “family contract” of the Sterlikovs (F.F. Sterlikov, Pavel Fedorovich Sterlikov, Marina Fedorovna Guskova (Sterlikova)) developed the activities. So, for example, in 2003-2005, half of all so far known unscrupulous defenses at the Russian State Humanitarian University (26 out of 52 fake dissertations) were passed. During this period, the defense of 20 dissertations out of 26 was accompanied by the Sterlikov family.Pavel Fedorovich Sterlikov, who accompanied the defense of four false dissertations, is himself the author of the linden. It consists almost entirely of incorrect borrowings, and on 58% of the pages of its main text contains copy-paste.
The sources of dissertations were mainly works prepared earlier at the Russian State Humanitarian University: repeated and reused texts that passed through the dissertation council were practiced - the texts of 40% of fake dissertations were completely or partially previously written or defended at the Russian State Humanitarian University. For example, a dissertation, which was prepared at the Russian State Humanitarian University, was subsequently used at least three times. Thus, the assumption that the members of the dissertation council at the Russian State University for the Humanities did not know about the practice of mass defenses of dissertations with plagiarism is untenable.
In addition, the Russian State University for the Humanities used a standard scheme for factories of fake dissertations, when the applicant borrowed the text of the dissertation of his supervisor or opponent, and the latter turned a blind eye to outright plagiarism and accompanied the fake dissertation with a positive review. For example, Irina Yuryevna Vaslavskaya, a leading researcher at the Institute of Economics of the Russian Academy of Sciences, opposed the text of her dissertation at the doctoral defense of Olga Eduardovna Fotina, now a professor at the Moscow State University of Technology and Management. K. G. Razumovsky, Valery Alekseevich Nazarov was the supervisor and source of the text for Vladimir Vasilyevich Barkanov, a deputy of the Legislative Assembly of St. Petersburg. M.F. did the same. Guskov and P.F. Sterlikov with his wards.
The network shown in the figure, however, does not show another important connection between the RSUH and the Military University. The dissertation council of the Military University often practiced repeated defense of the texts of dissertations from the Russian State Humanitarian University. Probably, the thesis of I.F. was defended at the Military University. Renich, specialty 01/20/07 "Military Economics" (his abstract, which could determine the place of protection, is not available in the RSL). The doctoral dissertation of the chairman of the dissertation council V.V. Minaev. The dissertation of V.V. Minaeva is no different from the linden who regularly defended herself at the Russian State Humanitarian University.
Thus, this once again confirms the thesis that the fish rots from the head.
The Fake Dissertation Factory has been operating at the Russian State University for the Humanities for at least ten years. V.V. Minaev, who was an expert of the Higher Attestation Commission and had the opportunity to control the process of awarding degrees directly at the Higher Attestation Commission. Yes, and F.F. Sterlikov, who worked for many years in the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation, probably had well-established connections there.
Dissernet's revelations played a role in the exclusion of V.V. Minaeva from the expert council of the Higher Attestation Commission. On January 11, 2015, the functioning of the dissertation council D 212.198.01 was also terminated “due to the inexpediency of continuing activities due to low performance” of the work. These are certainly important steps to eradicate fake dissertation factories. However, V.V. Minaev remains the head of the department at the Russian State University for the Humanities. Professors who actively participate in this network still work in universities and are members of other existing dissertation councils. For example, I.V. Ryzhov is a member of the Dissertation Council D 200.020.01 at the Russian Scientific and Technical Center for Information on Standardization, Metrology and Conformity Assessment, O.I. Pilipenko is on the board D 501.002.03 at Moscow State University.
In addition, Nadezhda Ivanovna Arkhipova, who took part in the work of the described network, has now been promoted to the position of Vice-Rector of the Russian State Humanitarian University and still remains an expert of the Higher Attestation Commission and Academic Secretary of the Council on Economic Theory, Finance and the World Economy.
Dissernet filed an application for the deprivation of academic degrees, the head of the administration of the Domodedovo urban district, and a deputy of the Kaliningrad Regional Duma, who defended themselves at the Russian State Humanitarian University. However, the dissertation council headed by V.V. Minaev, where the Ministry of Education and Science sent an application for re-examination of D.I. Gorodetsky and A.Yu. Gorokhov, unanimously stated that there was no plagiarism in their dissertations and that this was a political order for respected people. And because of the statute of limitations, there is no way to revoke the degree of most holders of fake degrees.
The example of the Russian State University for the Humanities clearly shows that none of the participants in the factory was personally punished and took responsibility for supporting fake dissertations. The dissertation council at the Russian State Humanitarian University was closed, however, according to the table, it is obvious that the Russian State Humanitarian University was just one of many platforms where dishonest professors covered up fake dissertations. Personal and business ties remain, and they can easily be realized, accompanied by linden in other dissertation councils.
Main membersfactories of fake dissertations of the Russian State University for the Humanities
| Fake dissertation maintainer | Job title | Scientific adviser | Opponent | Total in RSUH | Total in Russia |
| Sterlikov Fedor Fedorovich | Dr. economy Sci., laureate of the RF Government Prize in the field of science and technology, former head. Department of "Fundamentals of Economic Theory" of the Moscow State Institute of Electronics and Mathematics, Professor of the Institute of Economics and Anti-Crisis Regulation | 5 | 12 | 17 | 28 |
| Titova Natalya Evgenievna | Dr. economy Sci., Former Professor, Department of Theoretical Economics, Moscow State University of Technology and Management. K.G. Razumovsky, professor at the Institute of Economics and Management in Industry | - | 9 | 9 | 15 |
| Pilipenko Olga Ivanovna | Dr. economy Sciences, Professor of the Department of Finance and Credit of the Peoples' Friendship University of Russia, Professor of the Academy of Labor and Social Relations | - | 6 | 6 | 22 |
| Repnikova Valentina Mikhailovna | Dr. economy Sciences, Professor, Director of the Murmansk branch of the Russian Academy of National Economy and Public Administration under the President of the Russian Federation | - | 6 | 6 | 7 |
| Guskova (Sterlikova) Marina Fedorovna | Dr. economy Sci., Professor of the Department of Quality Management, Moscow State University of Communications, Professor of the Department of Economic Theory, Moscow State University of Medicine and Dentistry | 2 | 3 | 5 | 9 |
| Ryzhov Igor Viktorovich | Dr. economy Sci., Honorary Worker of Science and Technology of the Russian Federation, Professor of the State Academy for Advanced Studies and Retraining of Personnel for Construction and Housing and Communal Complex | 1 | 4 | 5 | 23 |
| Sterlikov Pavel Fedorovich | Dr. economy in Economics, Head of the Department of Economic Theory, Moscow State University of Medicine and Dentistry | 1 | 3 | 4 | 6 |
| Tebiev Boris Kaz-Gireevich (Konstantinovich) | Dr. economy in Economics, Professor, Department of Economic Theories, Russian State University for the Humanities | 1 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
Fake defenses in the Council on Economics of the Russian State Humanitarian University, 2003-2012 reviews. In fact, fake dissertation factories are an organized network of degrees for officials, businessmen, teachers, which has nothing to do with conducting research and increasing scientific knowledge. V.V. Minaev. Photo from the site www.rsuh.ru Above is one of these factories, which settled in the Russian State University for the Humanities (RGGU). Here are the authors of fake dissertations defended in the period 2003-2012 in one of the most "dirty" Russian councils on economics D 212.198.01, as well as their supervisors, opponents and authors of dissertations-sources. The chairman of this council was now a former member of the expert council of the Higher Attestation Commission on sectoral and regional economics, the current head of the department of world politics and international relations of the RSUH Valery Vladimirovich Minaev.
To date, Dissernet has discovered 52 fake dissertations defended in this council in 2003-2012, and during its investigations identified 148 more persons (supervisors, opponents, authors of source dissertations) who accompanied the process of defending fake dissertations. All two hundred factory participants turned out to be, as the figure shows, interconnected in a single network. The evolution of these connections is also clearly shown in the video. 
V.V. Minaev (2001). Table of borrowings The factory for the production of fake economists with degrees at the RSUH has its own characteristics. Of the 52 fake dissertations defended at the Russian State Humanitarian University, only 20 were directly prepared at this university. The remaining 32 dissertations were brought in from outside. The main supplier of linden is the Moscow State Institute of Electronics and Mathematics, where Fedor Fedorovich Sterlikov worked.
He personally participated in 17 unfair defenses at the Russian State Humanitarian University. It would be wrong to assume that only the odious Professor Sterlikov created a wave of plagiarism in this dissertation council. Undoubtedly, his role in this is great, however, in order to accompany 52 defenses, other scientific supervisors, opponents, and representatives of leading organizations are also needed. So, in the RSUH factory, 32 holders of scientific degrees directly participated in fake defenses at least twice. Among them there are also permanent actors who accompanied the lime as scientific advisers and opponents (see table).
The data indicate that a group of people from a number of “friendly” universities at that time (PFUR, Moscow State University of Medicine and Dentistry, Moscow State Institute of Electronics and Mathematics (MGIEM), Moscow State University of Railways messages, Moscow State University of Technology and Management named after K. G. Razumovsky, etc.), which systematically covered fake dissertations. Among them are the leaders of the Dissernet in the absolute standings: F.F. Sterlikov (28 dissertations, 17 of them at the Russian State University for the Humanities, I place), I.V. Ryzhov (23 theses, 5 at the Russian State University for the Humanities, IV place), O.I. Pilipenko (22 dissertations, 6 at the Russian State University for the Humanities, 5th place). 
F.F. Sterlikov. Photo from www.mgutm.ru In addition, the “family contract” of the Sterlikovs (F.F. Sterlikov, Pavel Fedorovich Sterlikov, Marina Fedorovna Guskova (Sterlikova)) developed the activities. So, for example, in 2003-2005, half of all so far known unfair defenses at the Russian State University for the Humanities (26 out of 52 fake dissertations) were passed. During this period, the defense of 20 dissertations out of 26 was accompanied by the Sterlikov family.
Pavel Fedorovich Sterlikov, who accompanied the defense of four false dissertations, is himself the author of the linden. His Ph.D. thesis consists almost entirely of incorrect borrowings, and his doctoral dissertation contains copy-paste on 58% of the pages of its main text.
The sources of dissertations were mainly works prepared earlier at the Russian State Humanitarian University: repeated and reused texts that passed through the dissertation council were practiced - the texts of 40% of fake dissertations were completely or partially previously written or defended at the Russian State Humanitarian University. For example, Igor Feliksovich Renich's dissertation, which was prepared at the Russian State Humanitarian University, was subsequently used at least three times. Thus, the assumption that the members of the dissertation council at the Russian State University for the Humanities did not know about the practice of mass defenses of dissertations with plagiarism is untenable.
In addition, the Russian State University for the Humanities used a standard scheme for factories of fake dissertations, when the applicant borrowed the text of the dissertation of his supervisor or opponent, and the latter turned a blind eye to outright plagiarism and accompanied the fake dissertation with a positive review. For example, Irina Yuryevna Vaslavskaya, a leading researcher at the Institute of Economics of the Russian Academy of Sciences, opposed the text of her dissertation at the doctoral defense of Olga Eduardovna Fotina, now a professor at the Moscow State University of Technology and Management. K. G. Razumovsky, Valery Alekseevich Nazarov was the supervisor and source of the text for Vladimir Vasilievich Barkanov, a deputy of the Legislative Assembly of St. Petersburg. M.F. did the same. Guskov and P.F. Sterlikov with his wards.
The network shown in the figure, however, does not show another important connection between the RSUH and the Military University. The dissertation council of the Military University often practiced repeated defense of the texts of dissertations from the Russian State Humanitarian University. Probably, the thesis of I.F. was defended at the Military University. Renich, specialty 01/20/07 "Military Economics" (his abstract, which could determine the place of protection, is not available in the RSL). The doctoral dissertation of the chairman of the dissertation council V.V. Minaev. The dissertation of V.V. Minaeva is no different from the linden who regularly defended herself at the Russian State Humanitarian University.
Thus, this once again confirms the thesis that the fish rots from the head.
The Fake Dissertation Factory has been operating at the Russian State University for the Humanities for at least ten years. V.V. Minaev, who was an expert of the Higher Attestation Commission and had the opportunity to control the process of awarding degrees directly at the Higher Attestation Commission. Yes, and F.F. Sterlikov, who worked for many years in the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation, probably had well-established connections there.
Dissernet's revelations played a role in the exclusion of V.V. Minaeva from the expert council of the Higher Attestation Commission. On January 11, 2015, the functioning of the dissertation council D 212.198.01 was also terminated "due to the inexpediency of continuing activities due to low performance" work. These are certainly important steps to eradicate fake dissertation factories. However, V.V. Minaev remains the head of the department at the Russian State University for the Humanities. Professors who actively participate in this network still work in universities and are members of other existing dissertation councils. For example, I.V. Ryzhov is a member of the Dissertation Council D 200.020.01 at the Russian Scientific and Technical Center for Information on Standardization, Metrology and Conformity Assessment, O.I. Pilipenko is on the board D 501.002.03 at Moscow State University.
In addition, Nadezhda Ivanovna Arkhipova, who took part in the work of the described network, has now been promoted to the position of Vice-Rector of the Russian State Humanitarian University and still remains an expert of the Higher Attestation Commission and Academic Secretary of the Council on Economic Theory, Finance and the World Economy.
Dissernet filed applications for the deprivation of academic degrees from Dmitry Igorevich Gorodetsky, the head of the administration of the Domodedovo city district, and Andrei Yuryevich Gorokhov, a deputy of the Kaliningrad Regional Duma, who defended themselves at the Russian State Humanitarian University. However, the dissertation council headed by V.V. Minaev, where the Ministry of Education and Science sent an application for re-examination of D.I. Gorodetsky and A.Yu. Gorokhov, unanimously stated that there was no plagiarism in their dissertations and that this was a political order for respected people. And because of the statute of limitations, there is no way to revoke the degree of most holders of fake degrees.
The example of the Russian State University for the Humanities clearly shows that none of the participants in the factory was personally punished and took responsibility for supporting fake dissertations. The dissertation council at the Russian State Humanitarian University was closed, however, according to the table, it is obvious that the Russian State Humanitarian University was just one of many platforms where dishonest professors covered up fake dissertations. Personal and business ties remain, and they can easily be realized, accompanied by linden in other dissertation councils.
Main membersfactories of fake dissertations of the Russian State University for the Humanities
| Escort lime dissertations |
Job title | Scientificsupervisor | Opponent | Total in RSUH | Total in Russia |
| Sterlikov Fedor Fedorovich |
Doc. economy. Sciences, laureate prizes Governments RF in areas science and technology, former head. department "Fundamentals economic theory" Moscow state institute electronics and mathematics, Professor Institute economyand anti-crisis regulation | 5 | 12 | 17 | 28 |
| Titov NataliaEvgenievna | Doc. economy. Sciences, former Professor kafedora theoretical economy Moscow state universitytechnologies and management them. To. G. RazuMoscow, Professor Institute saveki and management in industry | - | 9 | 9 | 15 |
| PilipenkoOlgaIvanovna | Doc. economy. Sciences, Professor Department "Finance and credit" Russian university friendship peoples, Professor Akademi labor and social relations | - | 6 | 6 | 22 |
| Repnikova Valentina Mikhailovna | Doc. economy. Sciences, Professor, formerdirector of Murmansk branch Russian academy popular farms and stateNoah services at President Russian Federation | - | 6 | 6 | 7 |
| Guskova(Sterlikov) Marina Fedorovna | Doc. economy. Sciences, Professor departments"Management quality" Moscow state university ways messages, Professor Department of Economics theories Moscow statedeed of gift medical- dental university | 2 | 3 | 5 | 9 |
| Ryzhov IgorViktorovich | Doc. economy. Sciences, honorable employee science and technology RF, Professor Sovereignnatural academy raise qualifications and retraining personnel for construction and housing- communalth complex | 1 | 4 | 5 | 23 |
| Sterlikov Paul Fedorovich |
Doc. economy. Sciences, head. department economic theories Moscow state medical- dentaluniversity | 1 | 3 | 4 | 6 |
| Tebiev BorisKaz- Gireevich(Konstantinovich) | Doc. economy. Sciences, Professor departments economic theories RSUH | 1 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
"Russian State University for the Humanities"
(RGGU)
ORGANIZATION OF THE WORK OF ACADEMIC SECRETARY
dissertational councils of the Russian State University for the Humanities
(PRACTICAL GUIDE)
Moscow 2013
Organization of the work of scientific secretaries of dissertation councils of the Russian State University for the Humanities: a practical guide. / RGGU; comp. ,
; Ed. . M., 20s.
The publication was prepared for academic secretaries of dissertation councils of the Russian State University for the Humanities on the basis of the “Regulations on the procedure for awarding academic degrees”, approved by the Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation (as amended by the Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation), “Regulations on the Council for the Defense of Dissertations for the Candidate of Science degree Doctor of Science”, approved by the order of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation, other provisions and instructive materials of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation.
The publication contains recommendations on organizing meetings of the dissertation council, preparing attestation documents for applicants, explanations and comments on the provisions that cause the most questions from scientific secretaries, and instructive materials on the organization of office work and the nomenclature of cases of the dissertation council.
© , comp., 2013. Ed.
© Russian State University for the Humanities, 2013
List of documents on the organization of the work of the scientific secretary of the dissertation council | ||
Organization of meetings of dissertation councils | ||
Preparation of attestation documents for applicants for the degree of Doctor / Candidate of Sciences | ||
List of documents generated in the activities of dissertation councils and subject to storage |
Applications
Attachment 1. | List of dissertation councils approved on the basis of the Russian State University for the Humanities | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Appendix 2 | Preparation of conclusions on the dissertation of the applicant for the degree of Doctor / Candidate of Sciences | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Appendix 3 | Official opponents and lead organization. Purpose, content and design of reviews, procedure for payment for opposition | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Appendix 4 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Appendix 5 | Submission of announcements on the defense of doctoral and master's theses on the websites of the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia and the Russian State University for the Humanities | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Appendix 6 | Presentation of the dissertation in the form of a scientific | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Appendix 7 | Conducting a one-time defense by the dissertation council | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Appendix 8 | On withdrawal of the dissertation from consideration in the dissertation council | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Appendix 9 | About defending a dissertation with a negative result | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Annex 10. | List of documents of the first copy of the attestation file of the applicant for the degree of Doctor / Candidate of Sciences, sent to the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia, TsITiS, RSL | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
P | The list of documents of the personal file of the applicant for the degree of doctor / candidate of sciences, stored in the dissertation council | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Annex 12. | On the award of doctoral / candidate of science degrees and the issuance of diplomas | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Annex 13. | Holding a meeting of the dissertation council when considering a dissertation sent by the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia for an additional conclusion | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Annex 14. | Common mistakes in the preparation of certification documents for applicants for a scientific degree | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Annex 15. | Forms of documents | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Announcement on the defense of the dissertation for the bulletin board of the Russian State University for the Humanities | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
The agenda of the meeting of the dissertation council | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
3. Preparation of attestation documents for applicants After defending a dissertation within a month Applicants, under the guidance of the Academic Secretary of the Dissertation Council, prepare attestation documents at the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia, the Federal State Autonomous Scientific Institution "Center for Information Technologies and Systems of Executive Authorities" (hereinafter - CITiS) and the Federal State Budgetary Institution "Russian State Library" (hereinafter - RSL). Documents to the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia, TsITiS and RSL are sent by the academic secretary of the dissertation council: to the expedition of the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia - daily, except Saturday and Sunday, opening hours from 09.00. - 17.00 (Monday - Thursday), from 09 Friday), lunch from 12 at the address: st. m. "Tverskaya", "Okhotny Ryad", Bryusov per., 21, under. 2. in TsITiS and RSL - through the post office (post office). Registration cover letters and information cards of dissertations (hereinafter referred to as ICD) for TsITiS is carried out in the Office of the Academic Council and Discussion Councils (room 426, Degree Applicants the doctors Sciences prepare attestation documents in the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia and TsITiS: certification case and the first copy of the dissertation are sent to the expedition Ministry of Education and Science of Russia · a mandatory free copy of the dissertation (in loose form), to which a cover letter is attached, two copies of the ICD of the established form are sent by mail to TsITiS (Presnensky Val str., 19, building 1, Moscow, Russia, 123557). Degree Applicants candidate Sciences prepare attestation documents in the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia, TsITiS and RSL: certification case is sent to the expedition Ministry of Education and Science of Russia obligatory free copy of the dissertation (in unbound form), to which a cover letter, two copies of ICD9 of the established form and a copy of the document confirming payment for registration of the dissertation are attached, is sent by mail to TsITiS(St. Presnensky Val, 19, building 1, Moscow, Russia, 123557); the first copy of the dissertation, to which is attached a cover letter, a copy of the abstract and a copy of the ICD - in RSL(Moscow, department of dissertations). On all issues of the work of dissertation councils, preparation of documents for applicants, the defense procedure, the academic secretaries of the dissertation councils of the RSUH, and, if necessary, applicants, can consult the Office of the Academic Council and Discussion Councils (room 426, and room 342, The leadership of dissertation councils, in particular, scientific secretaries, are responsible for the documents of applicants for a scientific degree sent to the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia, CITIS and the RSL. Failure to comply with the deadlines for sending personal files and documents of applicants leads to a delay in the issuance of diplomas. 4. List of documents generated in the activity The dissertation council keeps: organizational documents of the council (copies of orders on approval or partial change in the composition of the dissertation council, information about the members of the council and personal statements of council members about their consent to participate in the work, etc.); second copies of attestation files of applicants; · minutes of meetings of the dissertation council, including organizational ones; · attendance lists of meetings of the dissertation council, including organizational ones; In the Office of Provision organizational documents of the council (orders on the approval or partial change in the composition of the dissertation council, information about the members of the council, etc.); · annual reports on the work of dissertation councils of the Russian State University for the Humanities; · copies of ICD with a mark from TsITiS about the delivery of dissertations defended in the dissertation councils of the Russian State University for the Humanities; Documents for organizing a database on dissertation councils applications Attachment 1 List of dissertation councils, D 212.198.01 Specialties 08.00.01 - Economic theory 08.00.05 - Economics and management of the national economy
|
Deputy Chairman - Dr. Phil. sciences, prof. V. P. Filatov
Scientific secretary - Ph.D. philosophy Sciences, V. M. Karelin
Council members:
Dr. Sociology Sciences E. A. Grishina
Dr. Philosophy Sciences, Cand. philol. sciences, prof. I. V. Kondakov
Dr. Philosophy sciences, prof. M. A. Kukartseva
Dr. Philosophy sciences, prof. V. F. Levicheva
Dr. Philosophy sciences, prof. A. E. Lukyanov
Dr. Philosophy sciences, prof. E. N. Nekrasova
Dr. Philosophy S. A. Nizhnikov
Dr. Philosophy Sciences S. D. Serebryany
Dr. Philosophy sciences, prof. T. Yu. Sidorina
Dr. Philosophy Sci., Corresponding Member of the RAS Zh. T. Toshchenko
List of dissertations for the degree of Doctor and Candidate of Philosophical Sciences defended in the Dissertation Council D 212.198.05 from 2001 to the present
Doctoral dissertations
Antonov K. M. "Philosophy of Religion in Russian Metaphysics of the 19th - Early 20th Centuries", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Grigoryeva N. Ya. "The evolution of philosophical anthropology in the 1920-1950s: the radicalization of the image of man" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Ermishin O. T. "Historical and Philosophical Tradition in Russian Philosophy of the Late 19th - First Third of the 20th Centuries" specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
A. Isaev «Philosophical Thinking and Historical-Philosophical Concepts: Search for Unity in Existentially Oriented Philosophy of the 20th Century» specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Konacheva S. A. "Heidegger and philosophical theology of the twentieth century" - specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Kruglov A. N. “I. N. Tetens and the discussion about metaphysics in German philosophy of the second half of the 18th century, specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Kurabtsev V. L. "Philosophy of Lev Shestov in the context of the European religious and philosophical tradition" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Marchenko O. V. "The Philosophy of G. S. Skovoroda and Russian Philosophical Thought of the 19th - 20th Centuries" specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Savin A. E. "The formation of the transcendental-phenomenological concept of the history of Edmund Husserl" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Serebryany S. D. "Problems of understanding Indian culture", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Chernyakov A. G. "Time and Being in the Philosophy of Aristotle, Husserl and Heidegger", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Shchitsova T.V. "Birth and relationship between generations as a subject of analysis in existential-phenomenological philosophy" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
PhD dissertations
Aleksanyan A. G. “The process of inculturation of Manichaeism in China”, specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Akhtyrsky D. K. "Philosophical ideas in the work of D. L. Andreev" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Bandurovsky K. V. "The concept of the immortality of the soul in the philosophy of Thomas Aquinas and its historical and philosophical origins" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Belousov M. A. “Time and the possibility of experience: Kant, Husserl, Heidegger”, specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Brazhnikova Ya. G. "The Primary Experience of Being and the Phenomenon of Historical Time in the Philosophy of M. Merleau-Ponty", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Weiser T. V. "Community Ethics: J. Bataille and J. Habermas", specialty 09.00.11 - Social Philosophy
Vasilyeva S. V. "Anthropology, Theory of Knowledge and Ethics in the Philosophy of Max Scheler", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Vvedenskaya E. V. "Utopian ideas in the philosophy of Russian cosmism (N. F. Fedorov, K. E. Tsiolkovsky, V. I. Vernadsky)", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Golinevich N. A. "The problem of existence in the philosophy of M. Merleau-Ponty", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
A. Golubev, The Experience of Comprehension of Christian Dogmatics in the Works of Russian Religious Philosophers of the Late 19th - First Half of the 20th Centuries specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Gutsalov A. A. "Formation of the problem of intersubjectivity in the phenomenological philosophy of Edmund Husserl (1905-1927)" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Yermishina K. B. “The Image of Ancient Russia in the Historiosophy of the Russian Emigration of the 20th Century.” specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Zavorueva A. S. "The problem of transgression of anxiety in the life of modern society (social and philosophical aspects)" in the specialty 09.00.11 - Social Philosophy
Zaitsev D.A. "The Kiev-Mohyla school in its influence on Russian religious and philosophical thought in the second half of the 17th century." specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Kalkaeva A. B. "Philosophy of history of Liang Shumin" on specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Kartashov M. A. "The concept of "social Christianity" in the political philosophy of M. M. Speransky" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Kiseleva I. S. "The concept of "new religious ethics" by S. L. Frank" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Kovrevskaya V. E. "The problem of being in the philosophy of Thomas Aquinas" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Koretskaya M. A. "Perspectives of ontology in the optics of Heidegger and Deleuze", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Krupenina E. V. "Philosophical problems in the novels of Umberto Eco" on the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Kurennoy V. A. "The problem of the emergence of the phenomenological movement" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Loginov A. V. "Philosophical Anthropology of A. Gehlen", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Mikhailovsky A. V. “The question of technology. Criticism of the Epoch by Ernst Junger and Martin Heidegger, specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Mikhalev S. V. “The doctrine of truth in the philosophy of P.A. Florensky ", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Murzin N. N. "History and nothingness: the experience of comprehending the negative in Nietzsche's philosophy", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Namestnikova L. V. "The problem of faith and knowledge in the dialogical philosophy of Franz Rosenzweig" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Nguyen Thi Hong. "Features of the formation of the Buddhist tradition in Vietnam: past and present" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Osinovskaya I. A. “The Figurative Field as a Subject of Philosophical Research: Irony and Eros”, specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Pavlov K. A. "The problem of self-justification of the mind in classical and modern philosophy" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Pavlova E. D. "The hidden impact of the media on mass consciousness as a socio-philosophical problem" in the specialty 09.00.11 - Social Philosophy
Perekopskaya E. V. "The concept of art as a model of non-classical understanding of the essence of things in postmodern philosophy" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Piskunov V. V. “The concept of a social contract: classical and modern forms”, specialty 09.00.11 - Social philosophy
Podoroga Yu. V. "Images and concepts of duration in the philosophy of A. Bergson" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Predtechenskaya Yu. V. "The problem of the definition of the Absolute in Indian religious and philosophical thought: the formula of sat-chit-ananda and its reception in Christian theological literature" - specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Razumovsky I. S. "Philosophical language of I. V. Kireevsky: description, analysis, interpretation" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Samoykina A. A. "Problems of Husserl's Phenomenology in the Works of Russian Philosophers of the First Third of the 20th Century", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Samoilova O. G., The Experience of Metaphysical Reading of Artistic Creativity in Russian Philosophy of the Late 19th - Early 20th Centuries specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Sedakov N. E. "Archetypes of Being and Symbols of Culture (Carl Gustav Jung and Mircea Eliade)", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Sergeev K. V. "The Divine Comedy" as a philosophical text: to the history of ideas about consciousness in the Middle Ages, specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Sinelnikova N. A. "Metaphysical Anthropology of J. Marias", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Skvorchevsky K. A. "Metaphysics of the process: history and modernity" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Sukhno A. A. "Anti-repressive program: existential analytics and microphysics of the unconscious (based on "Being and Nothing" by J.-P. Sartre and "Anti-Oedipus" by J. Deleuze and F. Guattari) ", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Trubachev S. A. "Philosophical Anthropology of M. Landman", specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Tugareva M. V. "Irony as a semantic strategy of the Taoist canon "Zhuang Tzu"" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Ushakov V.V. "The concept of freedom in the moral philosophy of Leibniz and Kant" in the specialty 09.00.03 - History of Philosophy
Filatov S.V. "Corporate Communities: Historical Context and Modern Problems (Social and Philosophical Analysis)", specialty 09.00.11 - Social Philosophy